Thursday, April 11, 2013

Book review: The Ashford Affair, by Lauren Willig

I'm so glad the days of the sweeping generational saga are back. Downton Abbey and Kate Morton both deserve credit for this, and I couldn't be more pleased; my personal reading tastes have become fashionable at last!

The Ashford Affair is a departure for Lauren Willig in some ways but not in others. While leaving Napoleonic spies behind, she incorporates the same smart dialogue and multiple-time format in her newest book, which follows the lives of two women over 70 years apart who are linked through family ties and secrets. I sped through it in just under two days, regretting the intervening time when I had to go to work and sleep.

The heroines are Addie Gillecote, who arrives at Ashford Park, a grand English country house, in 1906 as an orphaned poor relation; and her granddaughter, Clementine Evans, a workaholic attorney in New York City in 1999. Clemmie's high-pressure legal career has resulted in a broken engagement and has made her late for her Granny Addie's 99th birthday party, to her mother's dismay.

Within the book's first chapter, a tantalizing genealogical problem presents itself. Clemmie also gets her first hint about a long-held family mystery when her grandmother, her mind drifting with old age or overmedication, calls her by an unfamiliar name. She becomes curious about the reason why and receives help in her quest from her aunt's stepson, Jon, a university professor with whom she shares witty quips (and memories of a weekend in Rome years ago that they've agreed not to talk about).

From the outset, the plot darts quickly among several eras and locales, forcing readers to trust the author to reveal each piece of her tale in its appropriate time. Fortunately the novel's structure is sound and easy to grasp.

Addie's changing relationship with her sophisticated cousin Bea sits at the center of the earlier storyline. Bea befriends Addie as a child and shelters her from the snippy remarks of her mother, Lady Ashford, who had opened her house to Addie only reluctantly. The two girls grow up together in a glittering prewar era of debutante balls and instruction in the social graces. But by 1926, when Addie arrives in Nairobi to stay with Bea and her husband Frederick on their coffee plantation, their closeness has become awkward... and it has everything to do with the as-yet-unknown past she shared with Frederick.

All of this takes place within the first few chapters, and I won't say more about what occurs. The background behind these situations is revealed bit by bit, and the telling held my attention throughout. The ending is fabulous, also, going one step above what I expected.

Historical fiction readers will likely take greater interest in Addie's story than Clemmie's, and not only because the earlier time period is intrinsically fascinating. These characters are moving through events that shaped the modern world, and the author illustrates how World War I shifted priorities and ruined lives, even those of the individuals fortunate enough to survive. The action sweeps from upscale Jazz-Age London soirees to the red dust and intense heat of Kenya; it succeeds at providing a wide-angle look at the times while tracing one woman's personal journey.

In addition, for me Addie was the more likeable and admirable character, doing her best with the lot she'd been given. Clemmie, while obviously a brilliant career woman, needs more than just a nudge to have her eyes opened to what truly matters in life, and with her frenetic schedule, it's no wonder she was unable to sustain a romantic relationship.

The Ashford Affair is billed as "bringing an Out of Africa feel to a Downton Abbey cast of characters," which is valid to some extent. I would have liked to have seen more of Addie's later life in Kenya, in addition to the nostalgic photographs which Clemmie comes across decades later, although maybe it's fitting that some aspects of the past remain elusive. As a saga, I found it very satisfying overall, and I'd certainly recommend it to anyone interested in the WWI and post-Edwardian eras.

Thanks to the publisher for providing an ARC as a FirstReads giveaway on Goodreads (this review was first published there in January). The Ashford Affair was published by St. Martin's Press on April 9th ($24.99, hb, 352pp).

12 comments:

  1. I was able to snag this one on the day of its release at my local library. The librarians are nice enough to set aside historical fiction for me after inventory and before the books go out on the shelf.

    I'm about 70 pages in and enjoying it alot. And you're right about Clemmie - I'm having a hard time relating to her.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's great you have first picks on historical novels at the library. Clemmie never really grew on me, even as the novel continued, although I did enjoy the modern half of the story.

      Delete
  2. I absolutely love Downtown Abbey and Out of Africa is one of my favorites so the Ashford Affair sounds promising.
    Great review,

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. One by one I'm reading through many of the Downton Abbey readalike novels, although I find I have to take a break between them so I don't hit overload!

      Delete
  3. I'm so glad that you enjoyed this one, Sarah. I have it waiting to be read, but won't likely be able to start it all that soon :-(

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Know where you're coming from there - I have too many books lined up to read. Hope you enjoy it when you get the opportunity to read it.

      Delete
  4. Anonymous12:08 PM

    I got an ARC from somewhere - and I must say that I am darn glad I never went to law school, because Clemmie's life as a 6th-yr associate in NYC sounded absolutely dreadful. Made me glad to be a public librarian!

    Sarah Other Librarian

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Given the author's background as an attorney, I'm sure Clemmie's career experience is realistic, too.

      Delete
  5. This is one book on my TBR.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Your review has me less apprehensive of this; I've had not great luck with Willig's Carnation series, but I'm a slavish Dinesen fangirl and love that era of history so I'm super intrigued. Will likely hate the contemporary storyline but am excited for the historical one!

    ReplyDelete
  7. This is a more serious work than the Pink Carnation series. The contemporary storyline was interesting when it focused on Clemmie's search for answers, but personality-wise, she was somewhat irritating. I've read that the author's writing another multi-period novel, and I'll definitely be on board for it.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I am looking forward to finally getting to read this book. I have been anticipating it for what feels like forever!

    ReplyDelete