Friday, August 12, 2011

Reviews of obscure books: Silk and Stone, by Dinah Dean

It's been well over a year since my last entry in the Reviews of Obscure Books series, so I figured it was about time for a new one.  This is my copy of Dinah Dean's Silk and Stone, and when you find a book as obscure as this one is, you don't care that one of its past owners slapped an ugly bookplate on the front cover rather than on the flyleaf.  Well, actually that's not true, but I'll deal with it.

Among others, Dean has written six mostly unconnected novels that take place in Waltham Abbey in Essex between the 11th and 19th centuries.  Silk and Stone, the 2nd in this unofficial series, is set during the civil wars between King Stephen and Empress Matilda in the 1140s.  But while the main characters all end up in the East of England, the novel begins on a pilgrimage far to the east and south.

Norman lady Mabilia de Wix, her 17-year-old daughter Elys, and their maid are in Rome, having traveled there in the company of Mabilia's haughty brother, Templar knight Sir Richard de Hastings.  Elys's older brother Matthew has a wound in his foot that refuses to heal, and the women have made pilgrimages to holy places all over England and France in the hopes of curing him.  All have failed, and they don't understand why.  Novelist Diana Norman would have made a slyly irreverent remark about this over-the-top situation, and indeed I expected one, but here, the novel's gentle humor mingles with sadness.  Unless Matthew lives, the family's noble line will die out.

If that's not bad enough, Elys hates the thought of going into a convent.  Mabilia has plans to retire to the cloister, seeing it as the safest place during these traumatic times of constant war, and wants to see Elys settled there too.  Elys's dowry has already been given to the nuns, so she has no hope for a decent marriage.  Elys has other plans, though.  An accomplished needlewoman, she thinks she has what it takes to be a professional broiderer.

The legendary tomb of King Harold II, which resides in Waltham
and is mentioned in the novel
Aylwin of Winchester, a master mason from a noble Saxon bloodline, sympathizes with Elys's predicament, and they become friends as he, his friend Sir Fulk, and her family wander back to England together.  Her quest for independence gains ground in the town of Waltham Abbey; she impresses Father Warmand with her skill, and he hires her to design and sew an elaborate cope, or church vestment.

With her unorthodox choice of career, her refusal to become a nun, her mother's and uncle's disapproval, and Sir Fulk's unwillingness to marry her despite his obvious admiration, Elys has her hands full.  Aylwin has feelings for her, but Elys is still blind to his attentions.  Matthew's days are numbered, too; only a miracle can cure him. Fortunately, one may be at hand.

This isn't a good book on which to test the 50-page rule.  Today's commercial fiction is obliged to grip the reader's attention immediately, but the initial few chapters of this one are slow.  Imagine the pacing of a pilgrimage in the Middle Ages, and you'll get an idea of how slow.  Things pick up as the plot begins to cohere, happily, and as Elys emerges as the novel's central figure.

Her plight is easy to understand who would want to be forced into a nunnery? but she belongs to her time rather than ours. Her romance with Aylwin develops realistically, with the shadow of the Norman Conquest, some seventy years earlier, still lingering in the background.  She also doesn't realize how fortunate she is, not until later.  Through the depiction of Elys's older sister Judith, who is now called Sister Helen, readers get to see the bitter result of a woman's regret-filled life.

The nave of Waltham Abbey
Dean presents a wonderfully detailed tapestry of the English medieval world, presenting the day-to-day occupations and concerns of nobility, craftspeople, and churchmen, although the weave isn't always as fine as it could be.  In some scenes, she spoon-feeds information on England's political history; in others, she drops readers into a pile of medieval terminology and lets them sort out what's what.  I liked the latter approach.  The word "mystery" is used in the sense of "miracle," and to her credit, Dean explores her characters' religious mindsets without making them seem holier-than-thou.  Instead, their faith feels like a natural part of their existence, which it was.

In her author's note, placed at the very beginning, Dean writes that many of her characters once lived, and that much of her plot is historically based rather than fictional.  Lady Mabilia, Sir Richard, Matthew, and several of the townspeople are among the real ones, all mentioned in a chronicle written forty years later.

Dinah Dean's Silk and Stone was published by Barrie & Jenkins, London, in hardcover in 1990 (382pp).  The RomanceWiki page has a complete bibliography of her work.  Should you be interested in a copy of this one, there are a couple of reasonably-priced ones on Amazon UK.  For now. 


  1. I need to read this series! I thought from the cover that they might be just historical mysteries, but the relatively obscure era in which this one takes place looks really interesting.

  2. Thanks for another great review, Sarah. I love novels set during the 12th century so I'll have to keep my eye open for this one at used book stores.

  3. I see what you mean about the cover, Susanna, it does look like a mystery from that, but it isn't. Some of Dean's other novels are historical romances.

    Thanks, Melissa! Hope you're able to find one.

    The first book she wrote set around Waltham is Daughter of the Sunset Isles, about King Harold's daughter, Gytha, who married the Grand Prince of Kiev.

  4. Really interesting. I'd never heard of Dinah Dean, but it's a great pen name,and the title has a ring to it. This one sounds interesting, I'll go on an online search to find out more.

  5. It may not be obvious from the review, but 'Silk and Stone' refers to the work created by Elys and Aylwin, respectively. Dinah Dean wrote under at least two other names and I'm not sure which of them is her real one - if any! But Dean is the most frequent one she used.

    It appears the cheapest copy of Silk and Stone was just bought on Amazon UK as it's no longer listed. I hope you enjoy it, whoever you are!

  6. Thanks, Sarah- I really enjoy your Obscure Books reviews. I thought I might buy a copy of Dean's "Daughter of the Sunset Isles", the story of King Harold Godwinsson's daughter, Gytha, who went on to marry into Russian nobility after the Norman Conquest. Until I saw the price-yikes! Might be an interloan, I think.

  7. Thanks, Annis. There's a copy of Daughter of the Sunset Isles on Amazon UK that's better than others price-wise (sans postage, anyway!) but I agree interlibrary loan would be best. I was looking forward to reading it given the subject - it's the only novel I know of about Gytha - but found it dry and uninvolving. I'll be interested to hear your thoughts!

  8. Oh dear, that doesn't sound too promising! A review at Amazon Uk seems to indicate that someone else found it fairly hard going as well. It can be quite difficult to adjust to the slower pace of older novels - we definitely expect our novels to get to the point more briskly these days- and given that we have so many more calls on our attention now, that's not unreasonable. I read Hella Haasse's "Tea Lords" not too long ago (review here ) . It was originally written in the early 1990s, and while I enjoyed it, I couldn't help but notice the leisurely pace - what a difference 20 years makes!

  9. I actually didn't finish it (yikes). Maybe I ought to give it another chance. I recently reread Anya Seton's Avalon and didn't mind at all the slower pacing - it could have been partly that, but it just seemed dry. Especially given the potential of the subject!

    I think I'd enjoy The Tea Lords. Her In a Dark Wood Wandering is one of my favorites. Thanks for the link to your review!

  10. Anonymous10:00 AM

    If you enjoyed this, you might like to know that 'Dinah Dean' wrote a number of other novels set during the Napoleonic Wars, in England or Russia. The Russian ones involve a set of characters, some of whom appear in each one of the books, and they give an interesting perspective on Napoleon's invasion of Russia, and life generally amongst the nobility in Tsarist Russia at that time. There is another book belonging to this series; 'The Green Gallant' written under the name 'Jane Hunt'. Hard to find. Several of her English novels were written as 'Marjorie May'
    Most of her books were published by Mills and Boon, but not all. The non-M&B ones are difficult to find.

    I would like to add that in her mediaeval books, skilled craftsmen referred to their craft as their 'mystery'. It doesn't mean 'miracle', it means an inborn skill which was thought to be a gift from God. When Aylwin carves his designs, he feels he is revealing what is actually in the stone, waiting to be uncovered.