Thursday, January 05, 2012

Book review: Curiosity, by Joan Thomas

It’s a current trend for historical fiction writers to re-examine neglected historical women and bring them back into the limelight. That said, one could hardly choose a better subject than Mary Anning, a carpenter’s daughter from the village of Lyme Regis in seaside Dorset, whose unearthing of and knowledge about fossils led to some of the greatest paleontological discoveries of her time.

The title of Joan Thomas’s Curiosity refers to the “snakestones” (see the gorgeous cover) and other curios that Mary finds and sells to wealthy visitors who arrive on the coach from Bath, as well as to the quickness of mind Mary displays throughout the novel.

The term "curiosity" could also apply to Mary herself. A woman who “would never truly be appreciated in a drawing room” due to her country ways and quaint accent, she grows from a bright, inquisitive child to an independent spinster who carves her own path in a world where female contributions to science are discounted.

For readers used to tales of courtship, fancy dresses, and elegant repartee in Regency England, Curiosity will present a refreshingly different side to the era. While the Napoleonic Wars rage elsewhere, practical, constant, and confident Mary pursues her passion with determination, despite discouragement from others and a family life plagued by malnutrition and misfortune. Her father dies relatively young, leaving enormous debts, and out of ten children, only she and a brother will survive to adulthood. She sells fossils to earn money to live on, but it's often not enough.

Her story is interleaved with that of Henry De la Beche, a man who in his own way is as much an oddity as she. The son of a Jamaica plantation owner, he is expelled from military college following a prank and discovers a scientific bent while examining the bones of birds caught in his chimney.

While staying with his unaffectionate mother and her new husband at Lyme Regis, he encounters Mary and thinks her a most unusual young woman, one of the only people with whom he's free to be himself. Little is known of Mary’s private life; while Henry’s support of Mary’s work is recorded, their gradual romance as described here is an imaginative re-creation of what might have been.

Both are trapped by the restrictions of their day: Henry by an unwelcome engagement to a society-minded girl, and Mary by her poverty and low place in a world that sees her interests as unnatural, and her fossils as possible manifestations of “the devil’s work.” Early 19th-century Britain sits at the cusp of scientific change, an era described in lucid and graceful language; no previous knowledge of paleontology is required.

At this time, with Darwin's Origin of Species some 40 years in the future, the ichthyosaur 12-year-old Mary so carefully excavates from limestone causes a flurry of questions to emerge. Did it perish in the Great Flood? Was coastal Dorset once a sea-bed, long ago? What is the meaning of a “day” in the Bible, if the specimens Mary finds prove to be much older than the accepted time of Creation?

One of Thomas’s greatest strengths is her ability to depict an entire realm of scientific debate and vigor through the seemingly limited viewpoints of Mary and Henry. Although her male peers in distant London take credit for her work, the novel rightly places Mary and Lyme Regis at the center of the activity. From the beautiful descriptions of the region – in which the area’s beaches and cliffs are layered with the remains of ancient creatures – to the characters’ dialogue, reactions, and social values, everything feels on point.

This is an invigorating and quietly compelling book, and while there are no dull or dry moments, some sections seem drawn out to a great degree. The depth of detail adds, though, to an extensive picture of the characters’ lives and times.  While Mary’s story is sometimes a sad one, readers should leave it feeling great admiration for her accomplishments, as well as appreciation for how Thomas has fictionalized her life with such care and poignancy.

Curiosity was published in 2011 by Emblem, an imprint of McClelland & Stewart, in trade paperback and is available at $21.00 in Canada and the US and at £14.99 in the UK.

20 comments:

  1. This seems like a very unusual book. Thank you for the review.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Oooh, this looks even better after reading your review than it did before! Lately I've been wary of historical fiction because of the "tales of courtship and elegant repartee." I will definitely have to pick up a copy...

    ReplyDelete
  3. This sounds interesting. I've read Tracy Chevalier's "Remarkable Creatures" which is also about Anning, I wonder whether both authors have imagined her in the same way.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Wow, this looks fantastic.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I've been reading some history on a parallel subject lately. Those 19th century amateur naturalists were fascinating, and especially when they crossed class boundaries.

    Thanks for the review. I'll put this one on my TBR list.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I haven't read Remarkable Creatures yet, though I've heard the books are very different in focus. Elizabeth Philpot is a minor character in this one. I also understand both authors came up with different ideas for Mary Anning's romantic interest!

    I didn't know much about Mary's life before this, so much of the details were new to me even though I could see where the story was going. One part about class boundaries which I found fascinating was Mary's conception of the different degrees of the poor; her family starts out at the top level - artisans - but, after her father's death and debts, they find themselves second to the bottom. The rich don't see these distinctions, but Mary and others of her class do.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I was just in Charmouth and Lyme Regis a few weeks ago and went fossil hunting with my aunt, uncle and nan. Hadn't heard of her before that but this sounds like a great read. Love the period and the subject. Temporarily out of stock at Amazon but added to my wishlist. Thanks for the review!

    ReplyDelete
  8. This sounds good. I will have to add it to my wish list!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Renate, that's fascinating; I've never been to that part of England.

    It's currently in stock at Book Depository - and cheaper too!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Great review! This sounds wonderful;!

    ReplyDelete
  11. This is one of my all-time favourite books. It made me swoon, sentence by sentence. And informative at the same time. I'm so glad you reviewed it.

    ReplyDelete
  12. What a great story. I've never heard anything about it. Thanks for reviewing it!

    ReplyDelete
  13. I appreciate all of your comments. Sandra, that's great to hear it's one of your favorites. I've been wanting to read Curiosity for some time, though until recently it wasn't readily available outside Canada.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Sounds fascinating. I generally avoid novels about Regency England like the plague but this sounds like it deserves a look. Thanks for reviewing it.

    ReplyDelete
  15. This book received a flurry of attention on public radio and other venues when it was published last year here in the States. I made a mental note to keep an eye out for it.

    Thank you for the reminder!

    Love, C.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hi Foxessa, I think you may be remembering Tracy Chevalier's Remarkable Creatures, which also has Mary Anning as a subject. That book did get a lot of local publicity! Curiosity was never published in the US, although the trade pb is distributed here (as well as in the UK). I haven't yet read Chevalier's version. It's one of these odd coincidences to have two books about the same person out at the same time!

    ReplyDelete
  17. I've read Chevalier's Remarkable Creatures & loved it. It would be interesting to read this book, too. Mary Anning was an interesting person. Remarkable Creatures made me curious enough to browse some nonfiction about her. :)

    ReplyDelete
  18. Anonymous3:14 PM

    I read a juvenile biography (or fictionalized one) years ago -don't remember much of it, but I have always remembered who Mary Anning was b/c of it.

    There is a recent biography of her - THE FOSSIL HUNTER by Shelley Emling.

    I tend to think of the 18th and early 19th centuries as "The Age of the Amateur Scientist" in Great Britain.

    Sarah Other Librarian

    ReplyDelete
  19. (Yet) another one for my TBR list. I much prefer stories about ordinary people to drawing room repartee, and I absolutely love Dorset although I've never made it to Lyme.

    I have not read the Tracy Chevalier book either, so on the list it goes. I have sworn to get through my unread pile before buying any more, so it may be a while.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Sarah -- I think you're right that I mixed the two up.

    I'd forgotten that there had been two novels dealing with this published around the same time. Maybe it was because of this a public radio program interviewed both authors, even though one of them wasn't here in the States?

    Love, C.

    ReplyDelete