Friday, April 08, 2016

Book review: Modern Girls by Jennifer S. Brown, set in NYC's Jewish tenements in the '30s

Set amid the Jewish immigrant community on Manhattan’s Lower East Side in 1935, Jennifer S. Brown’s engrossing debut novel, Modern Girls, features the intertwined voices of two women, mother and daughter, who both find themselves in the family way. Neither is happy about it.

For Rose Krasinsky, worn out from raising five children, a new pregnancy at 42 means her hopes of increased involvement in Socialist activism (and for more time to help rescue her brother, trapped in Europe with his family) must be set aside in favor of more childcare and never-ending housework. And for her 19-year-old daughter, Dottie, finding herself pregnant after an unexpected one-night stand means the end to a promising bookkeeping career – and, most likely, to her future with her longtime boyfriend, Abe.

The author beautifully re-creates the vanished world of Yiddish-speaking immigrants in Depression-era America. (Rose’s husband, Ben/Beryl, shares his name and heritage with my own great-grandfather, which was an added treat; many other family names appeared in the story, too.) The Jewish tenements of 1930s New York are crowded, bustling places where cooking smells spill over into adjacent apartments, Rose’s kosher kitchen ensures her family is properly fed, and residents cart their bedding to their building’s rooftop on muggy summer nights.

Among others who share their background, these characters feel at home, but assimilation into mainstream society isn’t easy even for first-generation Americans. An intelligent career woman, Dottie may be a whiz with numbers, but her status as the only Jew in her workplace doesn’t make her popular with the other gals.

Those seeking insight into the day-to-day lives of women from the last century will find themselves fully involved in the agonizing struggles Rose and Dottie endure as they ponder their choices. Although both live in the modern era, in a modern city, the options for women with an unwanted pregnancy are limited, and it’s not a secret they can keep for very long.

Complicating matters for both is that neither understands the other’s reality. Sacrifices made by Rose, as a young woman in Russia, have shaped her character; she loves her daughter but sees Dottie’s life as luxurious in comparison. Likewise, Dottie can’t imagine that her strict mother could ever comprehend how her situation came about. Through the double narrative, readers can sympathize with both simultaneously. The way each woman handles her dilemma is not resolved predictably – another of the pleasures of reading this warmhearted yet realistic novel – but in looking back, their choices make perfect sense for who they are.

Modern Girls was published by NAL this week ($15.00/C$20.00, trade pb, 363pp). Thanks to the publisher for sending me a review copy at my request.

9 comments:

  1. Sounds like a book I would really enjoy! Going on my kindle!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I enjoyed your review very much, Sarah, and I look forward to reading this book, which I have on library reserve. The story speaks to my heritage as well; my grandparents lived in Brooklyn and worked in a Manhattan sweatshop. Have you ever visited the tenement museum in the Lower East Side (I think it's on Orchard Street)? It's quite a place.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Larry. I'd be interested to hear your thoughts on the book. My grandmother also grew up in Brooklyn; her father, so she told me (he died when I was 5), owned a fruit stand and later drove a cab. I've never been to the Tenement Museum but will make a point of seeing it next time I'm in NY. From their website, it looks like they have some interesting tours.

      Have you ever read Eleanor Widmer's Up from Orchard Street? I have a copy but haven't gotten to it yet.

      Delete
    2. Have read and reviewed (https://novelhistorian.com/2016/05/12/love-and-guilt-modern-girls/) the book. I liked it very much and found it head and shoulders above many first novels. I do wonder about Rose's crucial decision, which I think runs contrary to her character, and Willie's parents were over the top, I think. But otherwise, a splendid book.

      Delete
    3. Thanks for mentioning your review, Larry (I'm still catching up on my blog reading after being away). And I'm glad you also enjoyed it. I rather agree with you on Willie's parents, though on Rose - perhaps her decision didn't jar as much for me since, in looking back afterwards, I could see some seeds being planted for it; that, and the author based her character and choice on a surprising incident in her own family history.

      Delete
  3. I've not. I may be confusing that without another book, but I'll keep an eye out for it.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This book looks FANTASTIC! I was planning on visiting the Tenement Museum last year in NYC but sadly, didn't get around to it. This is my family's heritage, too- Jewish immigrants from Russia to NYC and Boston. I cannot wait to read this!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Maybe next year, once BEA comes back to NY? I feel like I should see it.

      Hope you'll enjoy the book as much as I did! It was fun to read the characters' Yiddish expressions - many of which I haven't heard spoken in my family in a long time.

      Delete